Virtue of the West – Black Pigeon Speaks

Tara McCarthy and Brittany Pettibone talk to Black Pigeon Speaks about women and the West.

Tara McCarthy
the authorTara McCarthy
Tara McCarthy is the host of Reality Calls, a podcast dedicated to making Western Civilization great again. Tara is also the co-host of the show, Virtue of the West.


  • If we are going by the facts alone, the intellectual and psychological differences between men and women are nothing close to large enough to justify the various patriarchal ideas that float around on the Alt Right. If there is some sort of value-based rationale for patriarchy, then let’s hear it (diagrammatically, I can’t imagine how it would work, but I’m open to hearing it), but instead people like Black Pigeon and Devlin base their arguments on supposedly objective facts; the problem is that their facts are either grossly exaggerated or flat wrong. I batted aside most of these arguments in this essay.

    The hosts let Pigeon off the hook to easily when he dismissed the importance of the fact that there is only about a 5% difference in the voting patterns of men and women. Pigeon’s personal feelings about where the political center should be is irrelevant. It doesn’t matter where you put the center if the scale is the same for everyone, which it is, and on that scale women and men are only separated by five points.

    • Uhh. We base our values on tradition and the tradition of our people is patriarchy. Your points argument is ridiculous.

    • My friend, in case you haven’t noticed, we are at war. We are in a total civilizational crisis. What do women know about war? What do they know about self defense and strategy? Men have a genetic memory for this sort of thing. I think women are also more easily (((deceived))) and taken in by scams and subversion.

  • Brittany and Tara need to walk the talk by marrying white men of good character and bearing their babies. It wouldn’t bother me if they have to nurse their babies in front of the camera while conducting their interviews.

  • I found it annoying to hear Black Pigeon swear repeatedly for no good reason. He’s also too pessimistic about the inevitability of women voting “socialist”. Women were generally conservative until the era of television and television is dying off along with the rest of mass culture. Other than that, it was a good interview and he does good work generally.

    • A single soon as women took the vote everything in society changed. Women will always vote socialist, at least more than 50%

      • Yea they will vote for the state to force men to provide for them. When will women start to build houses, fell trees, lay concrete, etc….? Obviously never. They demand a police state to force men to provide for them. I would laugh if it weren’t so perverse .

        This movement is a joke if it doesn’t seek to restore natural, organic relations between the sexes.

        Lana and co. are good but if we ever succeed they need to be gone from public view and involved in women’s issues only. Like weaving, gardening, child rearing. They will be happier in that role anyway.

        • I think there can still be a valid role for women in public life. Certain women should be allowed to be public figures in order to set a good example, and help keep the cultural tone high. We need a cultural “aristocracy” to uphold healthy and traditional values.

      • Women’s suffrage is only one aspect of the problem. It isn’t the root cause, nor is it the only issue. We are really facing a perfect storm of massive problems. And the (((root))) of that problem is not knowing who we are and who our enemies are. Who is “us” and who is not “us”.

    • Women were conservative because they had an incentive to stick by their husbands. Voting left started when they figured out they can get protection and
      provision from the state. It’s not that they suddenly became evil or something, they are simply following their instincts and the current system lets them to run amok.

  • People should actually read “Starship Troopers”- by ROBERT HEINLEIN. A great philosophical book and on the US marines reading list.

    • When I served in the USMC there were several books on the Commandant’s reading list that we read as a unit and discussed openly. “Starship Troopers” was one of them. I remember everyone was nervous to talk about it, basically waiting for others to speak first. Back in those days we still had Warrant Officers. Our Chief Warrant Officer wanted us to explore ideas, take notes, and talk about what we were thinking. In retrospect it was far more open-minded than college.

  • “The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people’s money.” -Margaret Thatcher

    • Indeed she is. And she has a twin. The Alt Right has all the best women. Lana, Blonde In the Belly of the Beast, even Ann Coulter is pretty decent looking.

      Tara McCarthy is overshadowed by Britanny, but she is intelligent and presents herself well. She is a good role model for slightly more average women, and any average guy would be lucky to have a woman like her.

Leave a Reply